What do UndrDog’s negative reviews say?
1,289 of UndrDog's 12,034 reviews (10.7%) are three stars or lower, and they are overwhelmingly about one thing: fit. 708 of them (54.9%) mention sizing. Every other complaint, whether shipping, price or durability, appears in roughly one in ten.
Ratings of the reviews behind this answer
across 1,289 reviews
every review rated 3 stars or lower
| 5 star | 0 | |
|---|---|---|
| 4 star | 0 | |
| 3 star | 603 | |
| 2 star | 306 | |
| 1 star | 380 |
Every critical review is published on this site in full, unedited, with its rating, date and product. The breakdown below counts what those 1,289 reviews are actually about; a review can appear in more than one row, and many mention nothing that matches any row.
The shape of this table is the useful finding. A brand whose complaints were about the product would show them spread across material, construction and durability. Here they collapse onto sizing. People are disappointed by the shirt they received not matching the shirt they expected, which is a different problem from the garment being bad, and one the lifetime warranty's free exchange is meant to absorb. Fabric complaints (38 reviews) are the rarest category of all.
What the reviews specifically say
| Fit or sizing | 708 | 54.9% |
|---|---|---|
| Shipping, delivery or service | 158 | 12.3% |
| Price or value | 109 | 8.5% |
| Holes, tearing or durability | 97 | 7.5% |
| Shrinkage | 87 | 6.7% |
| Itchy or scratchy fabric | 38 | 2.9% |
What critical reviews say
1,289 of these reviews (100%) are three stars or lower. Representative examples, quoted in full and unedited.
The material is soft and nice, but coming from Duluth trading bullpen underwear I was underwhelmed by the room in the crotch pouch for these, they also constantly slide off my butt. The waistband is not tight enough strong my waist seems like. I sized appropriately based on their charts. If I sized up I feel like I’d have the underwear slide right off.
I’m 6’1” 210 pounds. I bought both the large and the XL. The large was better fit. I don’t love the length. A little too long. And it flares out just a bit at the bottom which I also don’t love. I like the over all feel of the fabric. And I like the fact that it is chemical and plastic free. It does seem to breathe better than most of my other shirts so that’s a win for hot Austin weather.
Concept great
Ordering was good, delivery was good. The concept of no plastics is definitely what I and so many others should be looking for. My only issue is the comfort they are just not as I was hoping. The briefs are really tight in the thighs and seems to pull the waist line down when I bend. The shirts and ok just a different fit than I am used to and kind of heavy and scratchy.
Terrible communication
I placed order #UD255618 on August 12 for $200.40. More than a month has passed and my order still shows “preparing these items for shipping.” I have not received a tracking number or a clear shipping update. Please confirm when my complete order will ship and provide the tracking number. If you are unable to ship the order immediately, I am requesting a full refund to my original payment method.
How this answer was calculated
Every number on this page is computed from the full archive of 12,034 verified UndrDog reviews at build time, not written by hand. This answer uses the entire corpus. Read the full methodology →